the path of engagement

Imagine this: You’re standing at a fork in the road, face to face with a binary decision. In one direction lies engagement with the world, with all its uncertainty, ambiguity, and insecurity. In the other direction, avoidance and evasion. You can either embrace reality, or you can turn away in denial and escapism. The choice you make will determine the course of events, not just in your personal life, but also in the larger world of society, culture, and the planet at large. 

This is precisely the nature of our predicament. Most obviously, it’s about our experience with planetary scale challenges like ecological overshoot but it’s also about our most intimate personal lives, our social relationships, our families, our friends, and our careers. How do we respond when faced with difficult dilemmas, hard conversations, and elephants in our rooms? Do we go towards the challenge or do we sink into willful blindness, distraction, and silence? The choice we make will drive our neurobiology and our brain circuitry, our identity, our character, and even our survival.

This is where we stand, not only at this moment in history but in every moment of our lives. Facing the inconvenient truths of our circumstances, we must decide. Are we going towards engagement, or are we running for cover? The choice might seem trivial in the moment but will be extremely consequential in the long run. The path you choose will reverberate and cascade across your personal life, society, culture, and even the biosphere itself.

In conventional conversations, we’re accustomed to thinking about environmental issues as matters of policy, politics, and legislation; climate and biodiversity challenges are nothing more than technical problems to be solved. But ultimately, our future rests on human psychology and our willingness to face the reality of our circumstances. This is the root of our predicament. If we fail to engage with the challenges of our lives and our world, our fate will be sealed. No amount of smart policy or technological wizardry will make up for our failure to face the inconvenient truths of our day.

the path of avoidance

On the one hand, the path of avoidance is easy to identify; we’ve all been there to one degree or another. We encounter the harsh realities of life and turn away into escape, denial, willful blindness. We declare ourselves to be helpless and powerless, we become passive, apathetic, and conflict avoidant. We skip the hard conversations as we double down on amusement, distraction and hedonism. And most of all, we turn to safetyism, described by author Jonathan Haidt as “…a culture in which people are unwilling to make trade-offs demanded by other practical and moral concerns. Rather than seeing safety as one concern among many, it becomes a sacred value.”

Likewise, the path of avoidance is closely related to the notorious victim narrative: “Things just fall out of the sky into my life. I’m not responsible.” Instead of dealing with reality, it’s so much easier to lapse into declarations of powerlessness. “My effort doesn’t matter... Nothing I do will make any difference.” In the process, we become sports fans of life. Instead of participating in the field of play with all its risks and dangers, we simply sit on the sidelines, wishing and hoping that our favorite players will carry the day. As a sports fan might put it, “I won’t make myself vulnerable to the uncertainty of engagement, but I’m happy to cheer on the people who do.”

Sometimes our escapism is obvious. Maybe we’re having trouble adapting circumstances, so we turn to drugs, TV, digital distraction, or mindless amusement. But in other cases, our escapism might actually look like success. Maybe we bury ourselves in work, material wealth, or status. Maybe we build great business empires and dominate the competition. To the outside observer, it might look like we’re engaged, but deep down, our behavior stems from our inability or unwillingness to sit with our personal or planetary predicament. Appearances aside, we’re nothing more than scared little children cowering under the covers.

In small measure, avoidance is something we all do; it’s very much a human universal. But as a consistent long-term approach to life, it’s wickedly counter-productive. When avoidance becomes our default response to the world, we sink ever deeper into a quagmire of stagnation. We experience a contraction of our capability, a narrowing of function, and a loss of potential. Catastrophically, life loses its meaning. We become bored and alienated. We lose our sense of relevance. In turn, we become increasingly vulnerable to anxiety and depression.

All of which would be tragic enough, but even worse, avoidance simply doesn’t work. We think it makes us safer, but the whole thing backfires spectacularly, especially when we come in contact with the inevitable adversity that life brings our way. Psychically unprepared for hardship, we crash and burn. Our stress levels skyrocket and in turn, our performance and function collapse. Avoidance sets us up for even more severe forms of adversity, hardship, doubt, fear, danger, risk.

This is the paradox of avoidant behavior: It’s easy at the outset, but disastrous later. It may feel like a solution to our anxiety, but it’s actually a formula for personal, social, and planetary catastrophe. In the extreme, the path of avoidance leads, not just to wasted potential and calamity, but long term changes to our brains, our identities, and our character. As any athletic trainer would tell you, there’s got to be a training effect here. Acts of engagement or avoidance are simply reps. We become what we do.

the path of engagement

In contrast, engagement begins with a sober, clear-eyed assessment of reality, a radical acceptance of the facts on the ground. We tell the truth about our condition, we take it on, we face the music, we bear witness and embrace responsibility. We bring our courage and sincerity to the encounter.

In turn, this puts us onto the path of adventure, with all its adversity, doubt, danger. Naturally, there’s risk involved and things may very well go sideways in the process. There’s a very real chance that you’ll suffer injury, loss, or hardship. Nevertheless, once the dust settles, you’ll walk away with some extremely powerful benefits. Most obviously, you’ll feel sense of meaning. You’ve taken up the challenge, tried your best and maybe suffered, but all of it was in service of something you believed in, something you understood as valuable.

But that’s just the beginning. By virtue of your effort, participation, and experience, you’ll feel an increased sense of function and capability, increased confidence and a powerful sense of relevance. In the process, you’ll experience life as more substantive and interesting. You’ll be more resilient. You fought the battle and survived. If necessary, you can do it again. It may be hard now, but it’s going to be meaningful later.

This path of engagement may feel unique and exceptional in the modern world, but it’s actually a common, archetypal theme in many traditional cultures. We see it in the way of the warrior and in the hero’s journey, popularized by Joseph Campbell. It’s an honorable path, a path to flourishing, and even a path to sapience. It’s also consistent with the creative orientation of the artist. Art, no matter the form, is always about engagement with the world, with ambiguity and uncertainty. There’s no avoidance here. No matter the form or the medium, art is always about participation.

communities of engagement

When we come to the fork in the road, it may feel like our choice is exclusively personal. “I” decided to take the path of engagement, or “I” decided to take the path of avoidance. But it’s not so simple. Our decision is driven, not by a disembodied, Cartesian “I,” but also by our personal histories, our genetics and physiology, and our culture. In particular, we’re moved by society and the communities we inhabit; we’re always under the influence of one another, moving us towards or away from engagement.

This suggests that we’d do well to consider the kinds of culture and community we inhabit. On one hand, maybe you’d find yourself immersed in a community of avoidance, a “poor me” group of shared victimhood. In this kind of setting, people dodge responsibility, complain about their lot in life, avoid risk, and seek refuge in distraction and amusement. These influencers will likely move you towards avoidance, apathy, and passivity.

In contrast, an engagement community is bonded in the belief that relevance matters. People are bonded in action, bonded in effort, bonded in the willingness to accept risk. In this community, mistakes are nothing and spirit is everything. People will celebrate your courage and your resolve. In the process, you’ll become kin with every other warrior, adventurer, seeker, rebel, artist, and revolutionary that has ever lived. Whenever possible, choose these people.

human in the arena

None of this is really new, of course. Traditional teachers have long advised us to take the path of engagement and to avoid avoidance. Even in the modern era, leaders have sometimes told a similar story. A prime example is President Theodore Roosevelt’s legendary “Man in the Arena” speech of 1910:

It is not the critic who counts; not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles, or where the doer of deeds could have done them better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood; who strives valiantly; who errs, who comes short again and again, because there is no effort without error and shortcoming; but who does actually strive to do the deeds; who knows great enthusiasms, the great devotions; who spends himself in a worthy cause; who at the best knows in the end the triumph of high achievement, and who at the worst, if he fails, at least fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who neither know victory nor defeat.

Now more than ever, this is the kind of attitude we need. As individuals and as a people, we need to walk the path of engagement. We may feel intimidated and powerless in the face of inconvenient truths, but avoidance will only lead to more suffering and heartbreak. Everyone has a voice, everyone can do something. Use whatever power you possess. You may well fail in the effort, but that is very much beside the point.